skip graphical navigation
  Error Message: Your browser seems to be misbehaving.
 
Zoops! An error occurred.
  • Your browser seems to be misbehaving.
  • That vote will not be counted!
Use your Back button to return to where you were.
To report this error, email zoom_tech@wgbh.org.
 


Tell us what you think about American Idol 9:
Your Reviews
 
  • Amanda, age 15 of Taunton, MA
    Crystal Bowersox rocks! I love her! I also love Lee, Aaron and Didi or whatever her name is!

  • Erin, age 11 of HI
    I love the show, but why chose Ellen? I think the only reason she's there is because she's popular... Anything to do with singing..?

  • Izzy, age 12 of Montreal, QC
    BEST SEASON OF AMERICAN IDOL EVER!! This show is awesome! Go Lee!!

  • Alicia, age 10 of Dallas, TX
    i thinke u should have not let big mike go

  • Uriyah of Boston
    Big Mike rocks!!! But what does Ellen DeGeneres know about singing???

  • Tabatha
    LOVE IT! Its my fav show! I love Shibon!

  • Caitlin, age 15 of Charlotte, NC
    I loved it in all the previous years, but it's just kinda going downhill now. It's never going to be the same without the three original judges. I'll watch it now sometimes if I have nothing else to do, but I'm not really following it like I always did before. There used to be a lot of really talented people in the other seasons, but no one this year has really grabbed me.

  • Andrea, age 13 of Dunnellon, FL
    i like American Idol because I wanna become a singer and it helps me out!!! I love it!!!

  • Leah, age 10 of Lansdale, PA
    I love American Idol!!! I watch it all the time!

  • Billy, age 11 of Horsham, PA
    Okay, but starting to get boring. Paula's gone, and Ellen replaced her. Wht does she know about singing? Used to be my favorite, but not anymore. I heard Simon's leaving, which'll make the only original judge Randy. There are no stand outs this year and they are starting to all sound alike. I only watch it when there's nothing else on.

  • Courtney, age 16 of Clinton, TN
    I don't like this season. The people on there can't sing that great. They should have got better singers. Two toes.

  • Lydia, age 14 of Broadalbin, NY
    I honestly think that this season's talent is lacking. I like a few, but only sometimes, and no one really stands out. I am not half as into it as usual. Also, as others I'm sure agree, Ellen doesn't add as much as expected. Just not very good this season...

  • Giselle, age 9 of Humble, TX
    I LOVE AMERICAN IDOL!!! But this year is, well, just NOT GOOD!! I think that Andrew Garcia should go home. Also, the guy that played the gutar should of stayed.

  • Lora, age 5 of Salinas
    I love american idol it is so cool to here other people sing. I give it five toes

  • Kate, age 12
    I like it as much as always, but I don't think Lilly Scott should have been disqualified. Or Lacey Brown.

  • Max, age 9
    THIS IS THE WORST SEASON OF AMERICAN IDOL EVER!!! I can't believe how horrible these people's voices are! The only good part of this season was the auditions because everyone was so bad it was hysterical! I give it a chopped off foot.

  • Dominique, age 12 of Fulton, NY
    its the best show ever. love it.

  • Emily, age 9 of TX
    This is a great season 1 I think that Ellen was a good addition to the show! Me and my friend watch it all the time! 5 toes!!!

  • Ali, age 14 of Los Angeles, CA
    Horrible!!! If you want to watch a show where almost everyone has a bad voice, this is it. The only interesting part is when Simon tells them how bad they are. Ever since last season this show is just going downhill. I don't think I'll even bother watching next season if it doesn't have Simon. This doesn't even deserve 1 toe.

  • Olivia, age 11 of Memphis, TN
    i love american idol even more now that elen is on the show. she is so funny and I love her!!!

  • Jess
    only the auditions are good... I think the rest stinks.

  • Carey, age 13 of Centralia, WA
    i love it. I watch it every night it comes on. I hope the guy with the baby thats african american will win. some day I will be there!!!

  • Kath of Ohio, IL
    I don't like it. its the most dreatful show their is. They need to take it off the air. I don't think kids should even watch it.

  • Grace, age 14 of OH
    It was good at first, but it's getting old.

  • Brittany, age 15 of Williams, OR
    It's pretty good so far. We have good talent this season.

  • Christi, age 14 of Huffman, TX
    I Love it it

  • Alyssa, age 13 of Rochester, NY
    I can't believe Ellen is going to be a judge. Oh well, at least she's funny.

  • Rachel, age 10 of Northandover, MA
    I LUV American idol!! It's gonna be boring without Paula fighting with Simon but Ellen is awesome!! I'm glad Simon didn't leave

  • Anna, age 11 of Hamden, CT
    American Idol rocks! I love what happens on the show.

  • Madi, age 13 of Lenexa, KS
    I miss Palua. And I have nothing against Kara, but I just think it should have said the way it was. With the 3 oringial judges. I think it's sad to see it all changing and it's not as good. American Idol is headed down hill with Simon leaving too! I don't think a lot of people are gonna watch next season.

  • Kitty, age 9
    Much better this season! I cant wait for ellen to come on the show.

  • Kelzy, age 11
    It has too many yuck stuff in it like yuck.

 
not yet implemented